Doug Ulman
Cancer survivor

Doug Ulman

Doug Ulman is a three-time cancer survivor and president of the Lance Armstrong Foundation.

Public Plan? Surprise - We've Already Got One.

It's the question of the day: is a public plan option necessary? The truth is, we're already several decades into a public plan. And for millions of Americans already in the Medicare, Medicaid and Veterans Administration pipeline, the answer to the question is yes.

The more relevant issue is whether a broader public plan will interfere with Americans' choices.

Most Medicare beneficiaries report satisfaction with the current system. In fact, a recent Commonwealth Fund survey found about the same percentage of Medicare and employer-sponsored beneficiaries report being satisfied with their insurance. This suggests that a public plan may work, as long as it remains an option.

The "x" factor is whether a public plan will cause other options to dry up. Will employers close down their private coverage and push employees towards a cheaper, government-run program? The Lewin Group estimates that the public plan premiums would be more than 20 percent cheaper. If the public plan is open to all, why wouldn't companies drop private coverage in favor of a Medicare-based public plan?

However, our public plan is in big trouble. The Medicare Trust Fund is expected to go bankrupt in 2017. In order to preserve the system, services will inevitably be cut. If a newly-conceived public option simply follows in Medicare's footsteps, disaster may be just a decade or two away.

The devil is in the details. A public plan must be sustainable for the long term and have a reliable funding source. It must also preserve Americans' ability to choose their method of coverage. For cancer patients in particular, who need access and coordinated care from many practitioners, this is absolutely essential.

By Doug Ulman  |  August 7, 2009; 2:29 PM ET  | Category:  Health Care Reform , Public option Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   StumbleUpon   Technorati  
Previous: Umpire or Play Ball, Not Both | Next: Consumers: "Give Us More Options!"


Please report offensive comments below.

Medicare,Medicaid and the VA are fine for those that are qualified for that coverage. There are millions of American citizens that are not. Too, there are many more millions that have health care through their employers and still can not afford the deductibles.
It is for those reasons and many more that this country needs a viable health care plan for everyone. It should not and the Obama plan will not preclude anyone's current plan should they choose to continue with it.
The only people who will suffer and lose anything under the proposed plan are the HMO's and those that are beholden to them; those that currently profit greatly from the "health care business". The Obama plan is far from perfect, but it is a start.

Posted by: bkuehn54 | August 8, 2009 10:12 PM
Report Offensive Comment

The comments to this entry are closed.

RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2010 The Washington Post Company