The League

This Could Be You!


Ever wanted to be in The Washington Post? Well, now you can. Each day The League's crack team of comment experts will review your comments and select the best one. That comment will appear in the Sports section and online the next day.

March 19th Winner: bigboid


In response to: How Would You Make OT More Fair?

The above is a decent proposal. Keep the sudden death, but first to score six in OT wins. Not bad.

I always thought the rule only needed to be modified just a wee bit: ensure both teams get at least one possession in OT. If the team that wins the coin flip (Team A) kicks a FG, then they have to kick-off to the opposing team (Team B) and then the contest is decided by that possession. If Team B can drive to a winning TD, great. If they have to punt, then Team A wins. If Team B also kicks a FG, then the next team to score wins. If Team A does not score on its first possession, then the normal sudden death rules apply. If OT ends tied, then we still have a tie.

My solution would eliminate the gripes about the current OT rules favoring the team that wins the coin toss. It would virtually force Team B to go for it on fourth down on its first possession of OT (provided Team A scored), because giving the ball back means a loss. It's a fairly simple concept, and it doesn't change the nature of the game. Both teams have to play both offense and defense in OT. I can't believe it hasn't been suggested before.

Posted by: bigboid | March 19, 2009 12:17 PM

By TOP COMMENTER  |  March 19, 2009; 3:58 PM ET  | Category:  Best Commenter , NFL Save & Share:  Send E-mail   Facebook   Twitter   Digg   Yahoo Buzz   StumbleUpon   Technorati  
Previous: NFL OT Unfair | Next: OT's For Postseason

The comments to this entry are closed.

RSS Feed
Subscribe to The Post

© 2011 The Washington Post Company